Study Shows Care Provided by NPs and MDs in Community Health Centers Does Not Differ

March 21st, 2017

A recent study conducted by George Washington University about how care provided by a nurse practitioner compares with care provided by a physician at community health centers shows it does not differ.

This newest paper on care in community health centers was published Feb. 24 in the journal Medical Care. “Findings from our study should be reassuring to patients who rely on community health centers for their care,” said Ellen Kurtzman, associate professor in the George Washington School of Nursing and lead author of the paper. “We found that care is likely to be comparable regardless of whether patients are seen by a nurse practitioner, physician assistant or physician.”

Dr. Kurtzman and her team used five years of data (2006-2010) from the Health Center subsample of the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. They analyzed 23,704 patient visits to 1139 practitioners and examined nine patient-level outcomes measured by three quality indicators (smoking cessation, depression, ordering/prescribing of statins for patients with high levels of fat particles in the blood), four service utilization measures (physical exams, number of health education services, imaging services and total number of medications) and two referral pattern measures (physician referrals and return visits). 1

“This study adds to the large body of evidence showing that the care that nurse practitioners provide in an ambulatory care situation where nurse practitioners have the same authority as primary care physicians, patients’ outcomes were comparable,” states Andrea Marcotte, MSN, FNP, GNP, WellOne Primary Medical and Dental Care’s Chief Medical Officer. “We know that some people still hold the opinion that a physician provides better care than advanced practiced nurses (APRNs), but we’re discovering more and more through patient outcomes, research studies and patient satisfaction surveys that this perception is changing.”

“With the increase demand for primary medical care, WellOne, like many other community health centers, has turned to nurse practitioners and physician assistants to fulfill staffing needs,” continued Marcotte. “As WellOne continues to grow, we are always looking for skilled and compassionate providers who embrace our mission of providing excellent primary medical, dental and behavioral health services to the residents of the Rhode Island communities that we serve. Our emphasis is to promote the highest quality of health for the individual and family as well as for the community.”

WellOne is one of nine community health centers in Rhode Island who employ nurse practitioners and physician assistants in their practices. According to Marcotte, WellOne currently employs 11 nurse practitioners, 2 physician assistants and 4 physicians at their facilities in Pascoag, Foster, North Kingstown and North Scituate.

1 “A Comparison of Nurse Practitioners, Physician Assistants and Primary Care Physicians’ Patterns of Practice and Quality of Care in Health Centers,” Kurtzman, Ellen T. PhD, MPH, RN, FAAN; Barnow, Burt S. PhD, Medical Care (official Journal of the Medical Care section, American Public Health Association).

Other Recent News

Coronavirus Testing

WellOne is excited to announce that we will be conducting COVID testing at the Department of Public Works in Burrillville by appointment on scheduled days when ordered by a WellOne… read more


Some things have changed‘¦.But many things have stayed the same‘¦.We are here for you‘¦To care for you. We are writing to let you know of some changes at WellOne as… read more

COVID-19 UPDATE 3/17/20

WellOne Operational Updates WellOne telephones will open at approximately 9:30 a.m. each day. Please do not come to WellOne unless you have an appointment and have called in advance. Please… read more

Coronavirus Update 3/2/20

Due to the growing concern about the COVID-19/Coronavirus, WellOne would like to assure our patients that we are following all recommended guidelines provided by the Rhode Island Department of Health… read more


WELLONE PRIMARY MEDICAL AND DENTAL CARE’S FUNDRAISER FEATURES MUSIC AND DANCING TO BRASS ATTACK February 25, 2020 – WellOne Primary Medical and Dental Care, a non-profit, Federally-Qualified Health Center, is… read more


December 2019 ‘” WellOne Primary Medical and Dental Care is pleased to announce it has successfully achieved the Patient Centered Medical Home (PCMH) status for its health center in Scituate,… read more


Congratulations to everyone at WellOne on achieving the 2019 Gold Seal Quality Improvement Award from the Health Resources & Services Administration (HRSA). The award recognizes WellOne as a Health Center… read more

Specialty Clinic Ribbon Cutting

WellOne Providers, Charles Fraser, MSN, APRN-FNP-C; Stephanie Pinto, MSN, APRN-FNP-C and Alice Mui, MSN, APRN-FNP-C, joined CharterCARE’s (3rd from left) Dr. Michael Alavian, a Urologist, in a symbolic ribbon cutting… read more


July 2019 — WellOne Primary Medical and Dental Care is pleased to announce the addition of Alice Mui, MSN, APRN, FNP-C and Sheila M. Murphy, PA-C to its team of… read more


April 2019 — WellOne Primary, Medical and Dental Care, a Federally Qualified Health Center with several offices in Rhode Island, has announced that it will partner with CharterCARE Health Partners… read more